Skip to content
Stop using now Food recall · FDA · Published August 24, 2026

Crystal Temptations Recalls Chocolatey Eyeballs Due to Undeclared Milk

Crystal Temptations recalls Little Temptations and Chocolatey Eyeballs products due to a packaging mix-up that hides undeclared milk allergens.

🇺🇸 FDA recall #H-0189-2027FoodCrystal Temptations ›
✎ GovInfoNow plain-language explainer

Crystal Temptations is recalling certain batches of Little Temptations and Chocolatey Eyeballs (Hazelnut Praline) because whey, a milk derivative, was present in the product but not listed on the packaging. This error poses a risk to individuals with milk allergies who might unknowingly consume the allergen. The company has not yet provided a specific remedy or return instructions for consumers. Read more at govinfonow.com/recall/2240392-crystal-temptations-recalls-little-temptations-chocolatey-eyeballs-hazelnut-praline-chocolatey.

Source Summary by GovInfoNow · govinfonow.com/recall/2240392-crystal-temptations-recalls-little-temptations-chocolatey-eyeballs-hazelnut-praline-chocolatey · Published November 17, 2026 · Updated November 17, 2026 · Official notice: FDA #H-0189-2027

Cite this page

“Crystal Temptations Recalls Chocolatey Eyeballs Due to Undeclared Milk.” GovInfoNow, updated November 17, 2026. https://govinfonow.com/recall/2240392-crystal-temptations-recalls-little-temptations-chocolatey-eyeballs-hazelnut-praline-chocolatey. Based on FDA recall #H-0189-2027.

The FDA announced on 2026-08-24 that Crystal Temptations voluntarily recalled Little Temptations and Chocolatey Eyeballs products due to a packaging mix-up that fails to reveal the presence of milk. The agency issued recall number H-0189-2027 for the Class II hazard.

How to tell if you have it

  • Brand: Crystal Temptations
  • Products: Little Temptations, Chocolatey Eyeballs (Hazelnut Praline Chocolatey Eyeballs) Spooks and Spells
  • Sizes/Containers: Card Header Bag - 10 oz., Acrylic Box - 7 oz., Eyeball Jar - 10.5 oz., Pouch Bag 16 oz., Tag & Bell Bag 11 oz.
  • Lot Codes: CARD HEADER BAG 2022602, 2022604, 2022610, 2142611, 217610, 2172627; ACRYLIC BOX 1222626; EYEBALL JAR 1222626; POUCH BAG 2112618, 2172607, 2172633, 2172639, 2242601; TAG & BELL BAG 1222626
  • Distribution: AZ, TX, VA, GA, MA, NC, IN, NV, CA, NJ, CT, OH, WY

The hazard

The product packaging mix-up resulted in items containing whey (milk) being distributed in packaging that did not reveal the presence of milk. This creates an undeclared allergen risk for consumers with milk allergies.

Context

GovInfoNow's records show other recent recalls of similar products include Winfield's CWB Chocolate Bar Recall: Undeclared Milk Allergen Risk (2026-04-27), Recall: The Better Bakehouse Donutful Donuts Due to Undeclared Milk (2026-08-17), and Cacao Art Recalls Crunchy Caramel Chocolate for Undeclared Milk (2026-01-20).

How to tell if you have this one

Check for products labeled 'Little Temptations' or 'Chocolatey Eyeballs (Hazelnut Praline Chocolatey Eyeballs) Spooks and Spells'. Look for specific container types including Card Header Bags (10 oz), Acrylic Boxes (7 oz), Eyeball Jars (10.5 oz), Pouch Bags (16 oz), and Tag & Bell Bags (11 oz). Verify the lot numbers printed on the packaging, such as 2022602, 2022604, 2142611, 1222626, or 2172639.

  • Brand
    Crystal Temptations
  • Category
    Food
Based on the official FDA remedy

What to do — step by step

  1. Stop consuming the product

    Do not eat any recalled Little Temptations or Chocolatey Eyeballs items due to the undeclared milk allergen risk.

  2. Check packaging details

    Verify if your product matches the listed lot numbers and container types from the recall record.

  3. Monitor for updates

    Since no remedy is currently stated, watch for official announcements regarding returns or refunds.

Where it went and when

Where it was distributed

Distributed in 13 states.

Alaska: not listedAKMaine: not listedMEVermont: not listedVTNew Hampshire: not listedNHWashington: not listedWAIdaho: not listedIDMontana: not listedMTNorth Dakota: not listedNDMinnesota: not listedMNIllinois: not listedILWisconsin: not listedWIMichigan: not listedMINew York: not listedNYRhode Island: not listedRIMassachusetts: yesMAOregon: not listedORNevada: yesNVWyoming: yesWYSouth Dakota: not listedSDIowa: not listedIAIndiana: yesINOhio: yesOHPennsylvania: not listedPANew Jersey: yesNJConnecticut: yesCTCalifornia: yesCAUtah: not listedUTColorado: not listedCONebraska: not listedNEMissouri: not listedMOKentucky: not listedKYWest Virginia: not listedWVVirginia: yesVAMaryland: not listedMDDelaware: not listedDEArizona: yesAZNew Mexico: not listedNMKansas: not listedKSArkansas: not listedARTennessee: not listedTNNorth Carolina: yesNCSouth Carolina: not listedSCDistrict of Columbia: not listedDCOklahoma: not listedOKLouisiana: not listedLAMississippi: not listedMSAlabama: not listedALGeorgia: yesGAHawaii: not listedHITexas: yesTXFlorida: not listedFL

FDA distribution: “AZ, TX, VA, GA, MA, NC, IN, NV, CA, NJ, CT, OH, WY” States read from FDA’s own wording; “not listed” means the notice does not name it.

States: Arizona, California, Connecticut, Georgia, Indiana, Massachusetts, Nevada, New Jersey, North Carolina, Ohio, Texas, Virginia, Wyoming.

Recall timeline

FDA published this recall 3 months after the firm started it.

1. Firm started the recall: Aug 24, 202612. FDA classified it Class II: Nov 3, 202623. Published in FDA’s Enforcement Report: Nov 11, 202634. Added to GovInfoNow: Nov 17, 202642026
  1. Firm started the recall
  2. FDA classified it Class II
  3. Published in FDA’s Enforcement Report
  4. Added to GovInfoNow

Dates from the agency record only; steps without a date are left out.

✎ GovInfoNow

Questions people ask

Where were these products sold?

The products were distributed in Arizona, Texas, Virginia, Georgia, Massachusetts, North Carolina, Indiana, Nevada, California, New Jersey, Connecticut, Ohio, and Wyoming.

Similar recalls

Latest food recalls

Keep exploring

Where this comes from

The facts (hazard, remedy, dates, manufacturer) are pulled from the official FDA recall record. The plain-language summary and step-by-step checklist are written by GovInfoNow to make the official notice easier to act on — they don’t replace it.

  • Official source: FDA Recall #H-0189-2027 (August 24, 2026)
  • Plain-language summary written by qwen3.6:35b-a3b on November 17, 2026, from the official record above. Not reviewed by a person — if it conflicts with the FDA notice, the notice is correct. Report an error on this page.
  • GovInfoNow is an independent service and is not a government agency. We republish official FDA recall data; we don’t issue, amend or administer recalls.
GovInfoNow is an independent guide. We are not FDA or any government agency. Always confirm details with the official recall.Data: CPSC · FDA · NHTSA · USDA