Stop using now Food recall · FDA · Published February 11, 2020

CSM Recalls Vanilla Buttercreme Frosting Due to Plastic Contamination

CSM Bakery Products recalls 35 lb. pails of Vanilla Xtra Smooth Buttercreme Frosting due to plastic polymer contamination. Check your lot code.

Plain-English summary generated from official FDA data by GovInfoNow · Published by Carlos Caban · How we make summaries

🇺🇸 FDA recall #F-0728-2020Food CSM Bakery Products ›

Stop using this now

Pieces of plastic polymer were introduced into the sugar system.

Take action

Contact the company

Recalling firmCSM Bakery Products1400 W 2700 N · Pleasant View, UT 84404-1260

✎ GovInfoNow plain-language explainer

CSM Bakery Products is recalling 10,080 lbs. of 35 lb. pails of Vanilla Xtra Smooth Buttercreme Frosting because pieces of plastic polymer were found in the product. The issue occurred during manufacturing at Brill Inc. in Tucker, GA. Consumers should check their products for specific lot codes to see if they are affected. Read more at govinfonow.com/recall/15931-csm-recalls-vanilla-buttercreme-frosting-due-to-plastic-contamination.

Source Summary by GovInfoNow · govinfonow.com/recall/15931-csm-recalls-vanilla-buttercreme-frosting-due-to-plastic-contamination · Updated October 11, 2026 · FDA enforcement record: FDA #F-0728-2020

Cite this page

“CSM Recalls Vanilla Buttercreme Frosting Due to Plastic Contamination.” GovInfoNow, updated October 11, 2026. https://govinfonow.com/recall/15931-csm-recalls-vanilla-buttercreme-frosting-due-to-plastic-contamination. Based on FDA recall #F-0728-2020 (https://api.fda.gov/food/enforcement.json?search=recall_number:%22F-0728-2020%22&limit=1).

The FDA announced on Feb. 11, 2020, that CSM Bakery Products is recalling 35 lb. pails of Vanilla Xtra Smooth Buttercreme Frosting due to plastic polymer contamination. The recall affects products manufactured by Brill Inc. with lot code 1000756607.

How to tell if you have it

Brand: CSM Bakery Products
Product: Vanilla Xtra Smooth Buttercreme Frosting
Size: 35 lb. pail
MDM #: 10203023
Lot/Batch Code: 1000756607
Best By Date: AUG/02/2020
Manufacturer: Brill Inc., Tucker, GA
Distribution: Nationwide

The hazard

Pieces of plastic polymer were introduced into the sugar system during manufacturing. The FDA classified this as a Class II recall.

Context

GovInfoNow's records show CSM Bakery Products has one other recall on record since April 26, 2016, involving Red Velvet Cake for peanut traces. Other recent recalls of similar products include Lactalis Canada Vanilla Creme Brulee (April 14, 2026), Wawa Cookies & Cream Milk (Feb. 17, 2026), and Publix Bran Flakes (April 16, 2026).

How to tell if you have this one

Look for 35 lb. pails labeled 'VANILLA XTRA SMOOTH BUTTERCREME FROSTING' with MDM # 10203023. Check the lot/batch code for 1000756607 and a best-by date of AUG/02/2020.

Brand
CSM Bakery Products
Category
Food

FDA recall event · 12 products

All 12 products in this recall

FDA lists each product line separately under one recall event. Check your product description, lot or code numbers against each row. Every row shares the hazard and remedy on this page.

Classification
Class II
Status
Terminated
Distribution
Nationwide.

Recall number	Product, codes & lots	Quantity
F-0720-2020	30 lb. cases of 480 1.0 oz frozen chocolate chip cookie dough, MDM # 10194622, Manufactured by Brill Inc. Tucker, GA 30084 1 866 982 7455 OR BRILLINC.COM; LOT/BATCH CODE: 1000756642, BEST BY DATE: JAN/28/2021 LOT/BATCH CODE: 1000758272, BEST BY DATE: JAN/29/2021	9,720 lbs.
F-0721-2020	30 lb. cases of 480 1.0 oz frozen chocolate chip with mini colored candy pieces cookie dough, MDM # 10194626, Manufactured by Brill Inc. Tucker, GA 30084 1 866 982 7455 OR BRILLINC.COM; LOT/BATCH CODE: 1000756627, BEST BY DATE: JAN/28/2021	3,210 lbs.
F-0722-2020	40 lb. pail GLAZE 'N SHINE donut glaze, MDM # 10198587, Manufactured by Brill Inc. Tucker, GA 30084 1 866 982 7455 OR BRILLINC.COM; LOT/BATCH CODE: 1000759189, BEST BY DATE: OCT/01/2020	15,360 lbs.
F-0723-2020	43 lb. pail GLOSSY WHITE ICING (1102507) donut icing, MDM # 10199098, Distributed by Krispy Kreme Doughnut Corporation 1814 Ivy Avenue, Winston-Salem, NC 27105; LOT/BATCH CODE: 1000756601, BEST BY DATE: SEP/30/2020	12,384 lbs.
F-0724-2020	45 lb. box SAFEWAY CHOCOLATE BUTTERCREME BASE, MDM # 10201865, Distributed by Safeway Inc. PO Box 99 Pleasanton, CA 94566-0009; LOT/BATCH CODE: 1000756583, BEST BY DATE: SEP/30/2020	36,585 lbs.
F-0725-2020	18 lb. pail SIMPLICIOUS CREAM CHEESE ICING 18#PL, MDM # 10202840, Manufactured by Brill Inc. Tucker, GA 30084 1 866 982 7455 OR BRILLINC.COM; LOT/BATCH CODE: 1000756589, BEST BY DATE: AUG/02/2020	1,440 lbs.
F-0726-2020	14 lb. pail PINK DECORATING BUTTERCREME FROSTING, MDM # 10202860, Manufactured by Brill Inc. Tucker, GA 30084 1 866 982 7455 OR BRILLINC.COM; LOT/BATCH CODE: 1000757497, BEST BY DATE: AUG/03/2020	560 lbs.
F-0727-2020	18 lb. pail READY ICE FUDGE ICING, MDM # 10202894, Manufactured by Brill Inc. Tucker, GA 30084 1 866 982 7455 OR BRILLINC.COM; LOT/BATCH CODE: 1000757786, BEST BY DATE: AUG/01/2020	1,920 lbs.
F-0728-2020	35 lb. pail VANILLA XTRA SMOOTH BUTTERCREME FROSTING, MDM # 10203023, Manufactured by Brill Inc. Tucker, GA 30084 1 866 982 7455 OR BRILLINC.COM; LOT/BATCH CODE: 1000756607, BEST BY DATE: AUG/02/2020	10,080 lbs.
F-0729-2020	43 lb. pail WHITE 'N GLOSSY ICING donut icing, MDM # 10203280, Manufactured by Brill Inc. Tucker, GA 30084 1 866 982 7455 OR BRILLINC.COM; LOT/BATCH CODE: 1000756602, BEST BY DATE: SEP/30/2020	12,298 lbs.
F-0730-2020	32 lb. pail SAFEWAY CREAM CHEESE ICING, MDM # 10203458, Distributed by Safeway Inc. PO Box 99 Pleasanton, CA 94566-0009; LOT/BATCH CODE: 1000758135, BEST BY DATE: AUG/02/2020	7,680 lbs.
F-0731-2020	22.5 lb. cases of 24 15 oz pouches CINNABON CREAM CHEESE FROSTING, MDM # 10236082, Manufactured by Brill Inc. Tucker, GA 30084 1 866 982 7455 OR BRILLINC.COM; LOT/BATCH CODE: 1000756588, BEST BY DATE: FEB/02/2021	11,272.5 lbs.

Based on the official FDA remedy

What to do — step by step

Stop using the product
Do not use or serve the recalled frosting if it matches the identified lot code.
Contact manufacturer for details
Call 1-866-982-7455 or visit BRILLINC.COM for further instructions on disposal or return.

Where it went and when

Where it was distributed

Distributed nationwide.

FDA distribution: “Nationwide.” States read from FDA’s own wording; “not listed” means the notice does not name it.

Distributed nationwide.

Recall timeline

FDA terminated this recall 10 months after the firm started it.

Feb 11, 2020Firm started the recall
Feb 19, 2020FDA classified it Class II
Feb 26, 2020Published in FDA’s Enforcement Report
Dec 23, 2020FDA terminated the recall

Dates from the agency record only; steps without a date are left out.

Similar recalls

Latest food recalls

Keep exploring

Link to this recall

<a href="https://govinfonow.com/recall/15931-csm-recalls-vanilla-buttercreme-frosting-due-to-plastic-contamination">CSM Recalls Vanilla Buttercreme Frosting Due to Plastic Contamination (GovInfoNow)</a>

Where this comes from

The facts (hazard, remedy, dates, manufacturer) are pulled from the official FDA recall record. The plain-language summary and step-by-step checklist are written by GovInfoNow to make the official notice easier to act on — they don’t replace it.

Official source: FDA Recall #F-0728-2020 (February 11, 2020) — FDA publishes no per-recall page; this is the official machine-readable enforcement record. Search FDA recalls for F-0728-2020 to see it in context.
Plain-language summary written by qwen3.6:35b-a3b on October 11, 2026, from the official record above. Not reviewed by a person — if it conflicts with the FDA notice, the notice is correct. Report an error on this page.
GovInfoNow is an independent service and is not a government agency. We republish official FDA recall data; we don’t issue, amend or administer recalls.