Super Store Industries-Turlock Dairy Division recalls Sunny Side Farms Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream; 48 oz. carton, 1.5 QTS (1.42L) UPC: 7-17544-20740 5 Allergens for Peanut
Super Store Industries recalls Sunny Side Farms Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream due to butter pecan flavor lid containing butter pecan ice cream instead of peanut butter cup. Allergen cross-contamination risk for peanuts and tree nuts.
Lower-risk recall
Some containers of ice cream in a Peanut Butter Cup flavor container have a Butter Pecan flavor lid and are filled with Butter Pecan ice cream.
Contact the company & request your remedy
What happened, in plain English
Super Store Industries is recalling Sunny Side Farms Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream because some containers have a butter pecan flavor lid filled with butter pecan ice cream instead of peanut butter. This mix-up creates a risk for people with peanut or tree nut allergies. Read more at govinfonow.com/recall/18776-sunny-side-farms-peanut-butter-cup-ice-cream-recall-butter.
Source Summary by GovInfoNow · govinfonow.com/recall/18776-sunny-side-farms-peanut-butter-cup-ice-cream-recall-butter · Updated October 6, 2026 · FDA enforcement record: FDA #F-1772-2018
Cite this page
“Sunny Side Farms Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream Recall: Butter Pecan Flavor Mix-Up.” GovInfoNow, updated October 6, 2026. https://govinfonow.com/recall/18776-sunny-side-farms-peanut-butter-cup-ice-cream-recall-butter. Based on FDA recall #F-1772-2018 (https://api.fda.gov/food/enforcement.json?search=recall_number:%22F-1772-2018%22&limit=1).
Why it’s dangerous
The ice cream product has a butter pecan flavor lid that contains butter pecan ice cream instead of peanut butter. This mix-up means people with peanut or tree nut allergies could be exposed to allergens during consumption.
Who’s affected
People who own or consume this specific ice cream product are at risk if they have peanut or tree nut allergies. The recall affects those who purchased the product with the UPC 7-17544-20740 between July 2019 and the best by date.
How to tell if you have this one
Check for the 48 oz. carton with UPC 7-17544-20740. The product includes a butter pecan flavor lid filled with butter pecan ice cream instead of peanut butter.
- Brand
Sunny Side Farms- Product
Sunny Side Farms Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream; 48 oz. carton, 1.5 QTS (1.42L) UPC: 7-17544-20740 5 Allergens for Peanut- Category
Food
What to do — step by step
Check Product Label
Look for the UPC 7-17544-20740 on the carton to identify the recalled product.
Questions people ask
Is this product safe for people with peanut allergies?
No, this product contains butter pecan ice cream instead of peanut butter, creating a risk for people with peanut or tree nut allergies.
What should I do if I have this product?
Check the product label for the UPC 7-17544-20740. If you have the recalled product, contact Super Store Industries for guidance.
Is there a risk of serious injury from this product?
The recall is for allergen exposure risk, not physical injury. There is no mention of a risk for serious injury in normal use.
Contact Sunny Side Farms
We’ve drafted a message you can send Sunny Side Farms to request your refund or repair — edit it as you like.
Subject: Recall F-1772-2018 — Sunny Side Farms Sunny Side Farms Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream; 48 oz. carton, 1.5 QTS (1.42L) UPC: Hello, I own a Sunny Side Farms Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream; 48 oz. carton, 1.5 QTS (1.42L) UPC: 7-17544-20740 5 Allergens for Peanut that is covered by recall F-1772-2018 from Sunny Side Farms. I’m writing to arrange the remedy described in the recall (a refund, repair, or replacement as applicable). Could you please tell me the next steps to resolve this? Thank you.
Similar recalls
Keep exploring
From people who’ve dealt with this
Experiences, tips, and questions from readers. Every comment is reviewed before it appears.
No comments yet — be the first to share your experience.
Where this comes from
The facts (hazard, remedy, dates, manufacturer) are pulled from the official FDA recall record. The plain-language summary and step-by-step checklist are written by GovInfoNow to make the official notice easier to act on — they don’t replace it.
- Official source: FDA Recall #F-1772-2018 (August 2, 2018) — FDA publishes no per-recall page; this is the official machine-readable enforcement record. Search FDA recalls for F-1772-2018 to see it in context.
- Plain-language summary written by qwen3:4b on October 6, 2026, from the official record above. Not reviewed by a person — if it conflicts with the FDA notice, the notice is correct. Report an error on this page.
- GovInfoNow is an independent service and is not a government agency. We republish official FDA recall data; we don’t issue, amend or administer recalls.