La Fontanella recalls 12oz Pizza Shoppe Pink Stuff Creamy Garlic Salad Dressing due to potential spoilage from increased lactic acid. Check UPC 896537002019 and lot codes 2505C-1 to 2505C-3 for affected products.
Potential for product spoilage (increased level of lactic acid detected in retain samples).
La Fontanella is recalling Pizza Shoppe's "Pink Stuff" Creamy Garlic Salad Dressing because samples showed higher lactic acid levels, which could cause spoilage. This means the dressing might go bad faster than usual, but it doesn't pose a direct health risk like illness or injury.
The dressing contains higher levels of lactic acid than expected, which can cause it to spoil more quickly. This spoilage might lead to an unpleasant taste or texture, but it does not cause illness or injury.
Anyone who bought the 12oz Pizza Shoppe "Pink Stuff" Creamy Garlic Salad Dressing with UPC 896537002019 and lot codes 2505C-1 to 2505C-3. People storing the dressing in warm conditions are most at risk of spoilage.
Look for the product labeled "Pizza Shoppe The "Pink Stuff" World-Famous Creamy Garlic Salad Dressing" with a 12oz net weight, UPC 896537002019, and lot codes 2505C-1, 2505C-2, or 2505C-3. The bottles are clear plastic with a twist lid and packed 6 per case.
Verify the UPC 896537002019 and lot codes 2505C-1 to 2505C-3 on the packaging to confirm if your product is affected.
The recall is due to potential spoilage from increased lactic acid, which may affect taste and texture but does not cause illness or injury. It is safe to consume if stored properly.
Spoiled dressing may have an off taste or smell, but the recall does not specify a visible sign of spoilage. Check the best-by date (12/05/25) and storage conditions.
No action is required for safety, but if you notice spoilage, discard it. The recall does not require discarding the product.
We’ve drafted a message you can send La Fontanella to request your refund or repair — edit it as you like.
Subject: Recall H-0051-2025 — La Fontanella La Fontanella Hello, I own a La Fontanella that is covered by recall H-0051-2025 from La Fontanella. I’m writing to arrange the remedy described in the recall (a refund, repair, or replacement as applicable). Could you please tell me the next steps to resolve this? Thank you.
Experiences, tips, and questions from readers. Every comment is reviewed before it appears.
No comments yet — be the first to share your experience.
The facts (hazard, remedy, dates, manufacturer) are pulled from the official FDA recall record. The plain-language summary and step-by-step checklist are written by GovInfoNow to make the official notice easier to act on — they don’t replace it.
