Total Saddle Fit Recalls Western Saddle Cinches Due to Fall and Injury Hazards

What was recalled

The U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) has issued a recall for specific Western saddle cinches manufactured by Total Saddle Fit. This action addresses a significant safety defect in equipment designed to secure a rider’s saddle to a horse, ensuring stability during riding activities. The recall focuses exclusively on the "Shoulder Relief Cinch," a product intended to hold the saddle firmly in place while providing comfort for the animal. If you have purchased this specific item from Total Saddle Fit prior to August 2021, it is critical that you review the details below to determine if your gear is among those affected.

The recalled items are leather cinches available in two standard colors: black and brown. These cinches vary in length, measuring anywhere between 24 and 36 inches, catering to different horse sizes and rider preferences. A key identifying feature of the recalled product is the placement of the "Total Saddle Fit" brand name, which is located near the buckle on the cinch itself. However, the most definitive way to identify whether your cinch is part of this recall is by examining its hardware configuration. The recall applies only to Shoulder Relief Cinches that feature a round buckle and lack a center elastic component. If your cinch has a different buckle shape or includes elastic in the middle, it falls outside the scope of this specific safety notice.

This recall was officially announced on June 26, 2025, but it pertains to products sold well before that date. Specifically, it covers all Shoulder Relief Cinches sold by Total Saddle Fit prior to August 2021. The company is actively contacting all known purchasers of these affected units to inform them of the defect and to provide instructions for a remedy. While the provided recall facts do not specify the exact total number of units sold or currently in circulation, the scope is defined by the sale date and the specific hardware description outlined above.

The purpose of this recall is to address a failure mode where the cinch can come apart unexpectedly. This defect poses a serious risk because if the cinch fails, the saddle may fall off the horse during use. The CPSC notes that Total Saddle Fit has received 19 reports of the cinch coming apart and the saddle falling off as a result. Among these incidents, there is one report of a rider fracturing their ribs due to the fall. Consequently, the company is offering free replacements to all customers who possess the defective round-buckle models without center elastic, along with pre-paid shipping labels for returning the original items.

The hazard, explained

To understand why this recall is serious, it helps to look at the physics of what happens when a Western saddle cinch fails. In normal riding conditions, the cinch acts as the primary anchor point that keeps the saddle secure on the horse’s back. It must withstand significant lateral and vertical forces as the animal moves, trots, canters, or reacts suddenly to stimuli. The "Shoulder Relief" design is intended to provide comfort by allowing more room for the horse's shoulder movement, but in these recalled units, the structural integrity of that design has proven insufficient under stress.

The core mechanical failure described in this incident involves the cinch coming apart entirely. When a cinch separates during use, it no longer holds the saddle in place. Because Western saddles are relatively heavy and designed to carry significant weight—including that of an adult rider—the sudden loss of tension causes the saddle to shift rapidly or fall completely off the horse’s back. This is not a minor slip; it is a catastrophic loss of stability.

The immediate danger to the rider comes from the unpredictability of this failure. When the saddle drops, the rider loses their primary point of contact and balance. There is often no time to react or brace for impact. The rider can be thrown forward over the horse’s withers, sideways off the flank, or in some cases, dragged if their foot remains caught in the stirrup. This mechanism of injury is consistent with many equestrian accidents where equipment failure leads to uncontrolled falls.

The severity of these injuries can be substantial. According to the recall records from Total Saddle Fit, this specific failure mode has already resulted in documented physical trauma. One reported incident involved a rider fracturing their ribs, which highlights the high-impact nature of such falls. Ribs are fragile bones that protect vital organs; a fracture often results from direct impact against a hard surface like the ground or the horse’s own body during the fall. Other potential injuries in similar scenarios include head trauma, spinal compression, and soft tissue damage from the sudden jolt.

It is important to note that this hazard is not theoretical. The manufacturer has received 19 separate reports of the cinch coming apart and the saddle falling off prior to this recall announcement. While the exact frequency relative to total sales volume is not specified in the available data, the consistency of these reports indicates a systemic defect rather than isolated manufacturing errors. The risk persists until the defective component is replaced with one that meets current safety standards.

In summary, the hazard is twofold: first, the mechanical failure of the cinch itself due to design or material limitations in units sold prior to August 2021; and second, the secondary trauma caused by the resulting fall. The absence of a center elastic component on these specific models means they lack the shock-absorbing flexibility found in newer designs, potentially contributing to the stress points that lead to separation. Understanding this mechanism underscores why immediate cessation of use is critical for rider safety.

Who is most at risk

When we talk about the risk posed by the Total Saddle Fit Shoulder Relief Cinch, it is important to look beyond just the mechanical failure of the product itself and consider who is in the saddle when things go wrong. The primary group at risk here is anyone who owns or rides with a Western horse saddle equipped with this specific cinch model. Because the hazard involves the cinch coming apart and the saddle falling off, the danger is immediate and physical. The rider is directly exposed to the impact of falling from a moving animal, which can range from a minor scare to a serious medical emergency.

While any rider can be affected by this failure, certain individuals may face higher consequences due to their physical condition or riding experience level. For instance, older adults who ride for recreation or therapy often rely heavily on the stability of their tack. A sudden loss of saddle security can lead to falls that result in fractures, particularly of the ribs, hips, or wrists, which take much longer to heal and carry greater health risks for seniors. Similarly, younger riders or those with less core strength may struggle to maintain balance if the saddle shifts unexpectedly, increasing the likelihood of being thrown from the horse.

The recall data highlights that there have been 19 reported incidents where the cinch came apart, including one serious report of a rider fracturing their ribs. This underscores that the risk is not theoretical; it has already resulted in tangible harm. Riders who use these saddles for activities that involve sudden movements, such as cutting, reining, or trail riding over uneven terrain, may be at even greater risk. In these scenarios, the forces placed on the cinch are higher, and the potential for a catastrophic failure during a critical moment is significant. The lack of center elastic in the recalled models means there is less shock absorption, potentially transferring more force to the buckle and leather stress points when the horse moves.

It is also worth noting that riders who may not routinely inspect their tack with a critical eye might be unaware that their cinch is part of this recall. The risk is particularly insidious because the product looks functional until it fails. Therefore, the most vulnerable individuals are those who continue to use the equipment without verifying its safety status. If you fit into any of these categories—whether due to age, riding style, or lack of recent inspection—it is crucial to treat this recall with urgency. Your safety depends on recognizing that the risk is not just about a broken strap, but about the potential for a fall that could change your life.

How to tell if you have the recalled item

If you own a Western saddle cinch from Total Saddle Fit, it is important to verify whether your specific product is part of this safety recall before taking any further action. The Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) has identified a specific subset of items that are at risk, so checking the details carefully will help you determine if your gear is affected. The primary focus of this recall is on the "Shoulder Relief Cinch," a product designed to hold the saddle securely in place on your horse. To confirm if you have one of these recalled units, you should start by looking for the brand name. The words "Total Saddle Fit" are clearly located near the buckle on the cinch itself. If you do not see this branding, your item is likely not part of this specific recall.

Once you have identified the brand, you need to examine the physical construction and design features of the cinch. The recall specifically targets models that feature a round buckle. This is a key visual identifier; if your cinch has a different style of buckle, it may not be included in this notice. Furthermore, you must check for the presence of center elasticity. The recalled items are characterized by having no center elastic on the cinch body. If your cinch includes an elastic section in the middle, it is generally not part of this specific recall group. Additionally, these recalled cinches are made of leather and come in two distinct colors: black and brown. While color alone does not confirm the recall, knowing that the affected items are available in these shades can help you narrow down your search if you are unsure.

Size is another factor to consider during your inspection. The recalled Shoulder Relief Cinches measure between 24 and 36 inches in length. If your cinch falls outside this range, it is less likely to be one of the affected units, though you should still verify other features. Most importantly, the date of purchase plays a critical role in determining eligibility for the free replacement program. This recall only includes cinches that were sold prior to August 2021. If you purchased your item after this date, it is not covered by this specific safety notice. To be absolutely certain, you can contact Total Saddle Fit directly via email at care@totalsaddlefit.com or visit their website at https://www.totalsaddlefit.com and click on "Safety Recall" at the bottom of the page for more detailed information and verification tools.

What to do — step by step

Your refund, repair, or replacement options

If you own a recalled Total Saddle Fit Shoulder Relief Cinch, the good news is that the company has established a straightforward and cost-free remedy to resolve the issue. You do not need to pay for shipping, replacements, or any portion of the process. Total Saddle Fit is handling the entire logistical burden, which means your only responsibility is to communicate with them and follow their specific return instructions. This approach is designed to remove any financial barrier or inconvenience that might otherwise prevent you from correcting a potentially dangerous piece of equipment.

The primary remedy offered by the manufacturer is a free replacement cinch. If you contact Total Saddle Fit, they will provide you with a new, safe unit to replace the defective one you currently possess. In addition to sending the replacement, they will supply you with a prepaid shipping label. This label is crucial because it ensures that returning your old, recalled cinch costs you absolutely nothing. You simply pack the original item securely and drop it off at the designated carrier location using the label provided. The company is also proactively reaching out to all known purchasers of these items, so keep an eye on your email or mail for their direct communication regarding this safety action.

To initiate this process, you can contact Total Saddle Fit through several convenient channels. You may send an email directly to care@totalsaddlefit.com, which is often the quickest way to get a specific reference number and detailed instructions. Alternatively, you can visit their dedicated recall page at https://www.totalsaddlefit.com/recall for immediate information. If you are browsing their main website at https://www.totalsaddlefit.com, you will find a "Safety Recall" link located at the very bottom of the page that directs you to the same resources. When you reach out, be prepared to provide details about your specific cinch, such as its color (black or brown) and length (between 24 and 36 inches), to help them verify your eligibility quickly.

It is important to understand why a replacement is the chosen remedy rather than a simple refund. The issue with these cinches is a structural defect that can cause them to come apart during use, leading to saddle failure. A monetary refund alone would leave you without a functional piece of equipment, whereas a replacement ensures your horse and rider remain secure. By accepting this free replacement service, you are not only resolving the immediate hazard but also ensuring that your equestrian gear meets current safety standards. Do not attempt to repair the cinch yourself or use it while waiting for instructions; stop using it immediately and wait for the official guidance from Total Saddle Fit.

What can happen if you ignore it

It is completely understandable to feel hesitant about stopping a cherished activity or going through the hassle of returning a product, especially when the item has been part of your routine for years. However, continuing to use a Shoulder Relief Cinch from Total Saddle Fit that matches the recalled specifications is not merely an inconvenience; it is a significant and unnecessary risk to both you and your horse. The core issue with these specific cinches is that they are prone to coming apart unexpectedly. When this failure occurs, the saddle loses its primary anchor point and can slide off the horse’s back without warning. This is not a minor malfunction that might result in a slightly loose fit; it is a catastrophic structural failure of the equipment’s safety function.

The consequences of ignoring this hazard are severe and well-documented by the manufacturer’s own incident reports. We have received concrete data showing that this is not a hypothetical risk but a reality that has already caused serious harm. Total Saddle Fit has documented 19 separate incidents where the cinch failed, leading to the saddle falling off. In one particularly alarming instance, a rider suffered fractured ribs as a direct result of the saddle detaching while in motion. Imagine the sudden loss of stability and balance that occurs when your seat support vanishes mid-ride. The physical impact of hitting the ground or being thrown from a moving horse can lead to fractures, head injuries, spinal damage, or worse. These are not abstract possibilities; they are the real-world outcomes that have already affected riders.

Beyond the immediate risk of falling, there is the danger of panic and secondary accidents. A saddle slipping off can startle your horse, causing it to bolt, spin, or rear in confusion. This creates a chaotic environment where you lose control not just of your own body, but of a large animal that may react unpredictably out of fear. Even if you do not suffer a direct fall, the loss of trust in your equipment can have lasting psychological effects, making it difficult to ride confidently again. The anxiety of wondering if your cinch will hold this time can overshadow the joy and connection you seek in equestrian sports.

Furthermore, ignoring the recall does not make the problem go away; it only delays the inevitable failure. These cinches were manufactured with a design flaw that affects their integrity over time. The round buckle configuration, which distinguishes these recalled units from newer models with center elastic, is inherently less secure under the dynamic stresses of riding. By continuing to use them, you are essentially gambling with your safety every time you mount up. The remedy offered by Total Saddle Fit is straightforward and free, but it requires action on your part. Choosing to ignore this recall means choosing to accept a known, documented, and potentially life-altering risk for no good reason. Your safety, and the well-being of your horse, is worth far more than the few hours it takes to contact the company and arrange a replacement.

Staying safe: broader tips

While this specific recall addresses a defect in a particular brand of western saddle cinch, the underlying principle applies to all equestrian gear: your safety depends on the integrity of every connection point between you and your animal. Equipment failure rarely happens without warning signs if you know where to look. The first line of defense is not just buying quality gear, but maintaining it with a rigorous, routine inspection schedule. Before every ride, regardless of how new or expensive the equipment appears, you should perform a tactile check of all stress points. For cinches and girths, this means running your fingers along the leather or webbing to feel for thinning, cracking, or fraying fibers. Check the stitching at the ends where the hardware attaches; pulled threads are an early warning sign that the load-bearing capacity is compromised.

It is also crucial to understand the lifecycle of your equipment. Even high-quality leather and synthetic materials degrade over time due to exposure to sweat, dirt, and UV light. Leather becomes brittle as it loses its natural oils, while webbing can weaken from repeated tension cycles. Establish a maintenance routine that includes regular cleaning and conditioning of leather parts, and replace any gear that shows significant wear, even if it hasn’t technically “broken” yet. Never assume that a piece of equipment is safe simply because it has held up under normal use in the past; fatigue is cumulative.

Beyond physical inspection, stay informed about safety alerts specific to your region and activity. The U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) maintains a public database of recalls that covers everything from children’s toys to outdoor power equipment. Subscribing to their email alerts or checking the site periodically ensures you are not caught off guard by defects in gear you may have purchased years ago. Additionally, consider registering your purchases with manufacturers when possible. This simple step often serves as the critical link between a company identifying a batch defect and reaching out to you directly with a remedy.

Finally, educate yourself on proper fitting and usage for all your tack. A cinch that is too tight can cause discomfort and behavioral issues in horses, while one that is improperly secured increases the risk of accidental release. Attend a clinic or consult with a certified saddler to ensure your gear fits both you and your horse correctly. Proper fit reduces unnecessary stress on equipment components, extending their life and enhancing safety. By combining vigilant maintenance, staying informed through official channels, and ensuring proper usage, you create a robust safety net that goes far beyond any single recall notice.